The “What Ifs”

By Branden Morgan, Pie in the Sky Media

Police sketch of a young woman tied to a tree.
Police sketch of Norma Jean Countryman bound to a tree. Photo: Clark County Sheriff's Office.

Ignored survivor, prolific killer.

Norma Jean Countryman escaped her abductor at age 15. She went to the police. She gave them everything: his name, his face, his van, the ropes, the weapon. But no one believed her. Not then. Not when it counted. And in the silence that followed, more girls would vanish.

Police sketch of a woman bound to a tree.
Artists rendering of Norma Jean Countryman bound to a tree in Dole Valley. Photo provided by Clark County Sheriff’s Office.

Episode 3 of Stolen Voices of Dole Valley examines the path of a serial killer following Norma’s report in July of 1974, likely emboldened by the fact that she wasn’t believed. We trace his escalating behavior, the way he adapted, evaded, and hid in plain sight. Through interviews with former detectives, survivors, and legal experts, we see how red flags were ignored, patterns overlooked, and dots left tragically unconnected.

Cropped photo of the Countryman family.
Norma Jean Countryman in the weeks after her attack, July 1974. Photo provided by Norma Jean Countryman.

Norma’s voice becomes a warning that went unheard. Her survival could have stopped a serial predator in his tracks. Instead, it marked the beginning of a much larger failure.

Listeners will come to understand the emotional toll of carrying a truth no one wants to hear—and the weight of responsibility when that truth is finally acknowledged, far too late.

What if they had listened?

What if they had believed her?

What if one voice—heard in time—could have saved them all?

  • apple
  • spotify
  • amazon